The Rogue Not Taken

MISERABLE MARQUESS MAKES MASSIVE MISTAKE

He returned to Lyne Castle as darkness fell, the dwindling light having already seen the house and its residents to their chambers—sun set late during a North Country summer. He was happy for the quiet and the dark—the best conditions for getting drunk. He would leave on the morrow, to his house in Yorkshire.

The library was obviously out of the question, as it was filled with her memory, and so he took himself to the only place he knew there was decent scotch. His father’s study.

He did not expect to find his father in residence.

And he certainly did not expect to find Agnes in his father’s arms.

They broke apart the moment the door opened, Agnes immediately turning away from the door. Good Lord—she was relacing her bodice.

Good Lord.

King turned his back on the tableau as quickly as he could. “I— Christ. I beg your pardon.” And then he realized just what he’d seen. His father, in flagrante, with Agnes.

His father, the duke, in the arms of his housekeeper.

“You may look, Aloysius,” she said quietly.

He turned back to them both, standing at separate ends of the great window at the far end of the study. He considered the duo, his father silver-haired and distinguished, and Agnes, as beautiful as she’d ever been.

He glared at his father. “What in hell are you doing?”

The duke raised a black brow, a smirk on his lips. “I imagine you’re well able to divine it.”

Agnes blushed. “George,” she admonished.

King couldn’t believe he’d heard it correctly. He’d never heard anyone refer to his father as anything other than his title. In honesty, it would have taken King a moment to remember his father’s given name.

Agnes did not even hesitate over it.

His father turned and winked at her. “We aren’t children, Nessie. He needn’t be so shocked.”

“I am, indeed, shocked,” King said, “How long has this—” He shook his head and looked to Agnes. “How long has he been taking advantage of you?”

They both laughed at that, as though King had told a wonderful joke.

As though he did not want to kill someone.

As though this day were not the single worst of his life.

“I do not jest,” he said. “What in hell is going on?”

“What is going on is that we’ve a houseful of visitors, and Agnes insists on our skulking about rather than telling the truth.” His father moved to a sideboard and poured two tumblers of scotch. He looked up at King. “Drink?”

King nodded, watching, flabbergasted, as the duke poured a third glass and delivered it to Agnes with a warm, unfamiliar smile before crossing to offer the remaining scotch to him. “What is the truth, Father?”

The Duke of Lyne met King’s gaze. “I love Agnes.”

If his father had sprouted wings and flown about the room, King could not have been more shocked. “Since when?”

“Since forever.”

Forever.

God, how he hated that word.

“How long is that?” King drank, hoping the spirits would bring reason.

Agnes replied. “Nearly fifteen years.” As though it were the most ordinary thing in the world.

He looked to his father. “Fifteen years.”

The duke met his gaze, all seriousness. “Since you left.”

Anger flared. And frustration. And not a small amount of jealousy. His father had had Agnes. He’d had no one. “You didn’t marry her.”

“I’ve asked her every day for the lion’s share of that time,” the duke said, looking to Agnes, and damned if King didn’t see the truth in that look. They loved each other. “She won’t say yes.”

King turned to Agnes. “Why in hell not?”

The duke put up his hands. “Perhaps you will understand it.”

Agnes ignored his father. “I’m a housekeeper.”

“Oh, yes. That’s much better than being a duchess,” King said.

“It is, rather,” she said.

And in her words, he heard Sophie, in her slippers, nose to nose with him on the Great North Road, lambasting the aristocracy and him with it. Arrogant, vapid, without purpose, and altogether too reliant on your title and fortune, which you have come by without any effort of your own. And somehow I am looking to trap you into marriage?

Agnes explained. “I don’t want the whole world thinking I trapped him. Thinking he’s saddled with me for some idiotic reason. I don’t want the aristocracy in our business.”

“Hang the aristocracy, Nessie,” his father said, going to her.

“Easier said than done,” Agnes replied, lifting her hand to his face, stroking his cheek. “I don’t wish to marry you. I wish to love you. And that will just have to be enough.”

The words crashed over him. He stilled. “What did you say?”

I didn’t wish to marry you. I only wished to love you.

I don’t wish for you to be saddled with me.

“Aloysius?”

How many times had she said it? That she didn’t want the marriage. That she wouldn’t go through with it.

How many times had he told her she no longer had a choice?

He’d made a terrible mistake.

He looked to his father. “But Lorna. You drove her away. You didn’t wish me to marry for love.”

“I drove her away because she was after your money. Your title.” His father took a deep breath, and said, “I never expected it to go the way it did. I never intended the girl’s death. I never intended your desertion.” Lyne drank deep before looking into his glass. “You had the anger of youth and I had the imperfection of age. I let you go,” he said to the amber liquid. “I never imagined you’d be so . . .” He trailed off.

Agnes finished the sentence. “. . . so like him. The two of you, so proud, so obstinate, so unwilling to listen.”

King watched his father, finally seeing the cracks in the great Duke of Lyne. Recognizing them, the way they broke the cool, unmoved façade, and made a man.

The duke looked to him. “You brought Lady Sophie to anger me. So I gave you what you wished. Because it is easier to be the man you wish me to be than the man I wish to attempt to be.” He looked to Agnes. “But I don’t think she’s after your title.”

Agnes smiled. “I’d wager all I have on her being after something much more valuable.”

I only wished to love you.

And he’d packed her in a carriage and sent her away.

He looked to his father. “I married her.”

His father nodded. “I spoke to the father today. He told me the girl had lost him quite a bit of investment. Something about Haven and a lake?”

“It was a fishpond.”

“Either way. He said he forced the marriage.”

Except he hadn’t. Not really. Sophie had said it herself; King could have refused. They were scandalous enough—she was scandalous enough—for no one to have questioned his decision.

But he’d wanted to marry her.

Even as he’d wanted to punish her, he’d wanted her for himself.

Forever.

“She didn’t want it.”

“Smart girl,” Agnes said, looking to his father.

She was smart. He didn’t deserve her. And she deserved infinitely better. “I forced it.”

“Smart boy,” his father said, meeting her gaze. “Perhaps I should post banns without your approval. Then you’d have to marry me.”

King set his glass down. “Scotland is faster.”

The duke raised a brow. “Gretna Green?”

“Warnick’s drive.” He closed his eyes. “We didn’t even say vows.”

It wasn’t true. She’d said them. She’d looked him straight in the eye, proud and strong and braver than he by half. And she’d said, loud enough for all to hear, “I do.”

And he’d never been so angry in all his life. What an ass he’d been.

His father grew serious. “Have you made a mess of it?”

She was alone in a carriage on her wedding night. When she should be with him. “I have.”

“Does she love you?”

“Yes.” He’d closed the door on the words, too busy pretending he could live a life without her now that he’d lived it with her. Pretending he could live a day without her. He looked to his father, and said the only thing that mattered. “I love her.”

The Duke of Lyne nodded to the door. “Then you’d best go repair what you’ve broken.”

King was already moving.

He tore through the empty night roads, stopping at inn after inn, finding no sign of Sophie. With each successive stop, he grew more frustrated, hope dwindling as he considered the mistakes he had made, desperate to find her and put them right.

How does it end?

I hope it ends happily.

It would. He’d make it end so. He’d find her. He’d sent her away, crying, and he would not stop until he found her, and made certain she never cried again. He’d ride straight to London without stopping if he had to. He’d meet her in Mayfair.

He’d do anything he could to make sure she never cried again.

He leaned into his steed and allowed himself, for the first time since he realized he loved her, to imagine what it would be to have her. Fully.

Forever.

He imagined her in his arms and in his bed and in his home, filling it with books and banter and babies. With babies. The line would not end with him any longer. He’d give her children—sweet-faced little girls with a penchant for adventure, just like their mother, who was the most adventurous woman he’d ever known.

From the moment he’d climbed down the Liverpool trellis, Sophie Talbot had led him on an adventure.

Sophie Talbot no longer.

Sophie, Marchioness of Eversley.

His wife.

His love.

Goddammit, would he never catch up to her?

The thought had barely formed when he came upon a sharp turn in the road and saw a coach several hundred yards ahead, exterior lanterns swinging in the dark. It was large enough to be the one he sought, and as he drew closer, he heard the thundering of hoofbeats, loud enough to be from six matched horses.

It was she.

He nudged his mount on, eager to reach her. To win her back.

To love her.

He’d get her a cat. Black. With white paws and a white nose. Perhaps then she’d forgive him.

Two hundred yards halved, and halved again, and again, and he could see that it was the right carriage as it approached the next turn in the road. Sophie’s carriage, emblazoned with the crest of Warnick’s clan on the back.

He couldn’t stop himself from calling out her name as the coach turned, “Sophie!” he called, pushing his horse harder, faster. He’d be alongside it in no time, and then he’d have her again.

If she’d have him.

The thought stung.

She would have him. He’d do whatever it took to win her back. He’d resort to any actions—he’d stop this carriage and hie her away on his horse, like a highwayman of yore. He’d take her somewhere beautiful and secluded, and right all his wrongs. He’d prove to her how well he could love her—better than anyone ever could.

He would spend the rest of his life proving it to her. “Lady Eversley!” he called this time, as though her married name could convince the universe that he deserved her.

He’d had enough of being away from her.

Now he wanted to be with her.

Forever.

The coach took the curve in the road, and King used the turn to draw closer. Close enough to hear the telltale pop as the inside front wheel strained. He’d heard that precise sound before, only that time, that night, he hadn’t understood what it heralded.

Fear overcame everything else.

“Stop!” he shouted, pushing his horse to its limits. Begging the steed to go faster even as he yelled, “Slow that carriage!”

It was too late.

The turn was too sharp and the carriage too large, and the wheel popped again. He screamed, “No!” desperate for the driver to hear him, but the word was lost in a mighty crack, followed by the screech of horses as the coach tipped, sending the coachman flying from the block before the vehicle toppled onto its side and was pulled along the road for a dozen yards before the terrified horses came to a stop.

“Sophie!” he screamed, leaping from his still-moving steed, desperate to get to her. “No! No no no,” he repeated again and again as he ran toward the carriage, unhooking a lantern and scaling it without pause, tearing open the door to find her.

Let her be alive.

Dear God, just let her live.

I’ll do anything for her to live.

“You must be alive, love. I’ve so much to tell you,” he said into the darkness, willing her to hear him. “I won’t lose you, Sophie. Not just as I found you. You’re not done with me, yet.”

It was dark inside, and he held the lantern high, searching for her.

“Live,” he said. “Live, please, God. Live.”

The words were a litany as he found the pile of silk—that beautiful purple gown she’d been wearing earlier in the day.

She wasn’t in it the dress.

She wasn’t in the carriage.

Relief slammed through him, blessed and welcome, his heart beating once more.

She was alive.

And on the heels of that realization came another, devastating one.

She’d left him.