Catcher drove his sedan. Jeff sat shotgun, while Mallory and I shared the back.
The night was dark, the country roads essentially empty and thankfully clear of elven armies. Still, every time we neared a streetlight or floodlight, my stomach clenched with fear that we’d see the outline of a battalion of soldiers cresting a hill, bows in hand and arrows ready to strike.
Catcher had dialed in Luc and Ethan. “Ladies and gents,” came Luc’s voice through the speakers. “Once again, you’re enjoying an adventure without me.”
“We don’t time them that way.” Ethan’s voice followed Luc’s. “And I’m not there, either.”
“As it should be,” Luc said. “At least you had sense enough not to attempt to lead this particular away team.”
“Star Trek,” I murmured, picking out one of Luc’s ubiquitous movie and television references.
“I have trained you well, Padawan.”
“You’re mixing your Wars and Treks,” Jeff pointed out.
“They’re interchangeable,” Luc said, earning a horrified look from Jeff. “Why don’t you give us the rundown on the carnival?”
I closed my eyes, trying to remember the layout. “It’s in the corner of the shopping center parking lot. A small carnival—five or six rides, a midway.”
“Semis or trucks?” Catcher asked. “I presume that’s how they’ve moved the carnival from town to town?”
“Not that I saw.”
“They probably park the trucks off-site,” Luc said. “Keep them out of the public eye. Merit, what else?”
“There’s a low fence—a gate—around it. Like a crowd-control barrier. Otherwise it’s open. The rides are mostly along the outsides, with the games and food in the middle. The attendants were pretty well dressed. They wore full outfits—costumes.”
As we neared the shopping center, my nerves began to light, my blood running faster, anticipating the coming confrontation. When a rock bounced off the windshield, I nearly fell to the floorboard, my heart palpitating with tangible fear. Post-elven stress disorder was no laughing matter.
But when Catcher turned the car into the shopping center, the parking lot was empty.
“What the hell?” he murmured.
“What’s wrong?” Ethan asked.
“They’re gone,” I said, hope deflating, and barely waiting for the car to stop before I opened the door and hopped out.
Everything was gone—the rides, the ticket booth, the games. The tourists and the carnies. Only the detritus of the carnival remained. The scents of fried food and exhaust, puddles of dirty water, scabs of black tape where cords had been adhered to the asphalt.
“We couldn’t have been that far behind,” I said, turning back to the group, who’d joined me in the lot. “You can still smell it.”
“Maybe they thought their luck was running out,” Mallory said, “so they decided to pick up camp and go.”
“Or maybe they accomplished their goals and they’re moving on to the next spot,” I said, blue that we’d missed our targets. Utterly.
Catcher turned back to the car. “Let’s get back to the Brecks’. Maybe Ethan can get Paige and the librarian started on where it might have gone next.”
I nodded, then glanced up at the shopping center. The grocery store was closest to the carnival, and it was the only shop still open. A few people milled around inside, visible between the stems and serifs of the giant gilded letters that advised passersby of sales and specials.
I gestured toward the store. “Why don’t I check out the grocery store? I’ll ask when the carnival left, if they know where it’s going next.”
“Don’t get kidnapped this time,” Catcher said. “Ethan gets irritable when you get kidnapped.”
“That’s only one of the many reasons he gets irritable,” I pointed out. “And I’ll do my best. But I make no promises.”
Considering the crimes we were investigating, that seemed best.
• • •
It was late, but the grocery store glowed with light and welcome heat. Disco played on the store’s sound system, and the cashier nearest the door smiled when I entered.
She couldn’t have been more than twenty, and she didn’t seem to mind the late hour or the dearth of customers. She filed her nails and hummed along with the music, a headband with fuzzy cat’s ears poking from her otherwise straight jet-black hair. She looked up at me and took in the katana when I walked over. Her eyes widened.
“Nice sword,” she said in a whisper when I moved closer. “That’s a katana, right?”
“It is, yeah,” I said with a smile. I’d forgotten I’d worn it, and appreciated that she didn’t feel the urge to signal the manager.
“Cool.”
“Thanks. Question for you.” I hitched a thumb toward the window. “The carnival that was here—when did it pack up?”
“I don’t know. Why? Were you hoping to win a goldfish?”
“Not exactly.” My prey was significantly larger, but I didn’t mention that aloud. “I don’t suppose you know where they were headed next?”
The front doors shushed open. A woman with short blond hair walked into the grocery store. She wore snug jeans and a short red cape with a hood. It barely reached her waist and was perfectly cut, the type of garment you’d see on a New York runway. A very expensive leather handbag—the kind my sister, Charlotte, might have bought in the stores on Oak Street—was tucked on her arm. She looked, I thought with a smile, like a very chic Little Red Riding Hood.
“No clue,” said the cashier, drawing my gaze again. “I’m not really into kiddie carnivals, you know?”
I took in the cat’s ears, the Rainbow Brite T-shirt. “You’ll appreciate them when you’re older. Thanks for the help.”
She shrugged and went back to her nails.
I walked toward the door but caught another glimpse of the girl who’d come in. She grabbed a red basket from a stack near the door and headed to the pharmacy aisle.
She looked familiar. I squinted, trying to remember the face and where I might have seen her. She wasn’t a shifter. Not an elf, certainly, with that haircut or fashion sense. And she was down a bow and sense of entitlement.
I walked quietly closer, pretending to be interested in hot cocoa mix, dandruff shampoo, frozen chicken dinners. She pulled supplies—bandages, rubbing alcohol, gauze—into her basket.
A clerk stepped in front of me, blocking my view. He was another teenager, this time with dark skin, short braids, and suspicious eyes. “Can I help you?”
I grabbed a box of soda crackers from the Willis Tower–shaped display in front of me. “Are these, you know, on special?”
He looked at me for a moment, gestured toward the display. “The sign says they’re two ninety-nine.”
“Awesome!” I perkily said. I turned to a nearby shelf and pretended to be very, very interested in wasabi-flavored popcorn. Actually, I didn’t have to try that hard. It was wasabi-flavored popcorn. I was already intrigued.
I waited a beat. Apparently satisfied that I’d only been nosy, and not pre-felonious, he disappeared. When the sound of his footsteps dissipated, I peeked around the end of the aisle again. The girl inspected the medical tape, and when a clerk approached and offered help, she waved him off with a smile, dimples at the sides of her cheeks. She turned just slightly, and I caught sight of her singularly gray eyes.
That’s when I knew where I’d seen her.
Her hair was different now, and her clothes. She was no longer a brunette, no longer wearing her uniform, no longer enticing customers into the Tunnel of Horrors. But there was no denying the smile.
She was the carnival barker.
Like a deer scenting a predator, her head popped up, her eyes scanning for trouble.
She caught my gaze, and there was a hint of a smile on her face. But she turned back to the tape, fingers skimming the boxes.
I walked around the corner, checked out a rack of plastic sunglasses while Lionel Richie crooned on the store’s music system.
The girl moved forward, disappearing into an aisle that, according to the sign hanging above it, held chips and soda.
Ever so quietly, I shifted closer, and when I reached the aisle, looked around the corner.
She was gone, but the thick rubber flaps that covered the entrance to the back room were swinging, and her basket was on the floor, the contents strewn about. She’d definitely made me.
And that wasn’t my only problem.
In her wake were scents much too familiar—sulfur and smoke. Dominic Tate, Seth Tate’s vanquished worse half, had smelled the same. But Dominic was dead; I’d seen Seth destroy him. Seth had left Chicago, and his scent had been different—lemon and sugar, like freshly baked cookies.
We hadn’t known any other Messengers, as the dueling angels had once been called. And yet, here I was, standing in a grocery store that smelled like the devil’s front porch.
I muttered a curse and took off, following her through the flaps and into a cold room that stank of overripe produce and cardboard. The room was large, with a polished concrete floor and office built into a corner. I ran to the office. A man in a collared short-sleeved shirt sat at the desk, munching on a sandwich. Roast beef, by the smell of it.
“You can’t be back here!” he yelled, over a mouthful of beef and bread.
“Just passing through,” I promised, then hurried down a narrow hallway to a storage area. This one held ten-foot-high stacks of boxes and wooden pallets. There was a back door across the room, but no one in sight.
“Can we just talk?” I asked, peering around a mountain of soda cartons, and caught a glance of blond hair hurrying away when a skyscraper of pallets rocked like a children’s block-stacking game. As always, gravity won.
I jumped aside and missed the falling tower, tripped over a box behind me, and ended up on my ass one way or the other.
Footsteps echoed through the room.
“What the hell is going on here?” asked the meaty voice behind me. The back door clanged shut as the woman slipped through it.
I rose, ignoring the manager and his threats of police calls and litigation, but decided to send a little thank-you to Papa Breck in consideration for all the kindness he’d shown us.
“The Breckenridges will be happy to pay for any damages,” I said, jumping over the messy pile of pallets and vaulting toward the back door. I slammed through it only to see her dart across the drive that ran behind the shopping center to the chain-link fence that separated it from the next property. A scrubby and empty lot, by the look of it.
I ran to the fence, jumped up a few feet, and began to climb. There was nothing remotely movielike about it, or elegant. The chain link wasn’t securely attached, and it bobbed beneath my feet like I was climbing a rope ladder. I hit the top, felt skin slice as my palm caught one of the bare prongs of chain link. Ignoring the pain, I threw my body over the top and hit the ground.
Only then did I recall the fact that I could have simply jumped over the damn thing. Maybe the House library was the place for me.
The girl was already running full out across the lot, which was pockmarked with piles of dirty snow, frozen hillocks of dirt, and construction debris. Something had been planned for this space, but considering the cracked and peeling WILL BUILD TO SUIT sign that lay abandoned on the ground, it wasn’t going to be finished anytime soon.
She ran with the long-legged grace of a marathon runner. I had vampiric speed and enhanced bone and muscle, but she was the running type, with a long stride and smooth motion that made it look completely effortless.
She reached a large concrete pad, hopped onto it, glanced back, searching the darkness to see if I was still behind her.
Because I was busy watching her, and not the ground in front of me, I didn’t see the ditch until it was too late.
I fell down into the three-foot-deep depression, hit my knees on the ice and inches of muddy water that had accumulated in the bottom. The fall jarred me, and it took a moment to get my brain unscrambled. I got back onto my feet and toed up a knobby dirt incline until I was at ground level again.
I spat out a curse that would have raised even my liberal grandfather’s hackles, and put my hands on my knees to catch my breath.
She was gone.
• • •
“She couldn’t have just disappeared,” Catcher said.
We stood on the edge of the lot, surveying the darkness, eyes straining for any sign or scent of the girl who’d so handily eluded me.
“She disappeared,” I assured him, trying my best to squeegee mud from my leather pants. “I hit a ditch, wasn’t down for more than a few seconds. When I looked up, she was gone. And she’s fast. I never got closer than ten feet, and that was in the building. Out here, she was like a rocket.”
“Supernatural?” Jeff asked.
“Actually, yeah.” I glanced at Mallory, worried how she’d react. “She smelled like smoke and sulfur.”
Jeff frowned. “Smoke and sulfur?”
He might not have understood the connection, but Mallory clearly did. She paled. “Like Dominic Tate. It’s what the fallen smell like.”
“Oh, damn,” Jeff murmured, clearly understanding.
“Dominic’s dead,” Catcher said.
“Seth said there could be more Messengers out there.”
“But not the fallen ones,” Mallory said. “They were magically bound together into the Maleficium. Seth and Dominic only separated because Claudia kept Dominic safe all those years ago.”
Or so we thought. This, I feared, was not going to help Mallory’s recovery—having the Messengers and Maleficium thrown back in her face again.
“I’m sorry,” Mallory said. “If this has anything to do with me, I’m sorry.”
Catcher rubbed her back. “Let’s not worry about what she is right now. Let’s think about who she is and how we can find her.” He looked at me. “Did she have any other physical characteristics we can search on? Piercings? Tattoos?”
“Nothing. Clothes looked expensive. Hair was blond, short. She had darker hair on the midway. It must have been a wig.” I glanced at Catcher and Mallory. “Can you do some kind of searching spell and find her?”
“Locating spells are actually pretty complicated,” Mallory said. “They don’t work like bloodhounds. Otherwise we’d just use that box of stuff from the storage locker to find Aline. We’d have to have something substantial—something marked by her magical signature.”
If only she’d whipped that expensive purse at me.
“Maybe the grocery store had security cameras,” I suggested, looking at Jeff. “Could you do something with facial recognition?”
“I’ll ask,” he said, already thumbing his phone.
“What was she buying?” Catcher asked.
“Medical supplies—bandages, gauze. That kind of thing.”
“So either she’s a conscientious employer or a zookeeper with wounded animals,” Catcher suggested.
I nodded. “If she’s still here getting supplies, the carnival can’t be too far away.”
“The trucks pulled out about half an hour ago,” Mallory said with a smile. “I followed up with the store. Pretended I had no clue why a woman had wreaked havoc in the back room. Made a few pithy comments about the state of the world, and the cashier opened right up.”
“Cat’s ears?” I wondered.
Mallory frowned. “What?”
She clearly hadn’t spoken to the same cashier. “Never mind. Continue.”
“So, Rhoda—that was her name, Rhoda—said the carnies kept to themselves, but before and after shift they’d come into the store for provisions. Snacks, drinks, deli food, booze, depending on the mood. She likes to travel—she and her husband have a camper—so she tried to make conversation about their route, but they wouldn’t talk about it. Paid for their gear and left again.”
“Even if the cashier had known where they were going next,” I said, “there’s a good chance they’ll change their schedule. She knew we’d found her. Took one look at me and bolted.”
“So where do we think they’ll go next?” Mallory asked.
I smiled mirthlessly. “You’re looking to add to your collection of sups, and you’re an hour from the Windy City, which has the largest proportion of vampire Houses in the nation, not to mention nymphs, trolls, and God knows what else. I’ll give you one guess: You aren’t going to Disneyland.”
• • •
We drove sullenly back to the Breckenridge house, none of us thrilled that we’d been so easily thwarted.
As we neared the house, we began to pass cars. A single car here and there, and then groups of four or five in succession. It was more traffic than I’d ever seen on the rural road that led to the estate.
“The shifters are going home,” Catcher said, as we pulled into the driveway. There was something sad about that—it was morose that they’d departed under such unfortunate circumstances. Or maybe it was just the magic in the air, or the growing absence of it.
Gabriel met us at the door, Ethan beside him. We migrated into the front parlor, now empty of shifters, and out of the cold.
“Nothing?” Gabriel asked.
I shook my head. “They’re gone.”
“The entire carnival was packed up, moved out,” Catcher said. “Merit found one of them in the grocery store, chased her down, but wasn’t able to nab her.”
Gabriel lifted slightly amused eyes to me. “That true, Kitten? Did you actually miss your prey?”
I decided not to tell him that I missed her because I fell in a ditch, as that would only add a thick layer of humiliation to the existing regret. I settled for glum.
“I missed her,” I confirmed.
“And I might have found her,” Jeff said, rocking proudly on his heels. “I was busy on the ride back.”
I thought the backseat had been quiet. “Grocery store footage?”
“Yes, ma’am.” He pulled out a sleek square of glass that looked like a miniature version of the screens in the Brecks’ operations room, began to skim his fingers across it. The glass went smoky and nearly opaque, and images and text began to scroll across the front.
“Another new toy?” I asked. I wasn’t much for gadgets, but it looked so deliciously tactile.
He kept his eyes on the screen, but a corner of his mouth perked up. “A portable to match the rest of the hardware. And here we are.” He held up the glass, swiveling it so the rest of us could see.
“That’s her,” I said immediately, recognizing the light hair, dark eyes, dimpled cheeks. The shot, remarkably clear, was taken at the front entrance of the grocery store.
“The grocery store was robbed about a year ago, and they invested in some quality hardware. I told them we were investigating the dark-haired girl with the leather jacket”—that was me—“and the manager was more than happy to pass the photo along.” He lifted his gaze, grinned full out. “He also asked about billing Papa Breck for the damages. Said they’d agreed to pay.”
Gabriel flicked a glance my way.
“Technically, we were there on Pack business.”
“We’ll pay the store,” Gabriel dourly said. “And we’ll remember this incident the next time we hire vampires to do our dirty work.”
“Do that,” Ethan said. “And consider paying us next time instead of extortion. But back to the girl?”
“Her name,” Jeff said, flipping the screen back and typing furiously, “is Regan, and I only found that because she’d been interviewed in one of the older articles about the carnival we uploaded. No last name, no date of birth, no last known address.”
“Much like the carnival,” Ethan said, “her history has been wiped.”
“Indeed,” Jeff said. “She’s now a ghost. Except for the grocery store footage, anyway.”
“Ghost may not be too far off,” I said. “She smelled like Dominic Tate.”
Gabe’s and Ethan’s reactions were pretty much the same as ours had been—surprise, doubt, concern.
“Dominic Tate is dead,” Ethan said.
“He is. And there shouldn’t be any other fallen angels out there. But I know what I smelled.” I’d been held by Dominic Tate in a prison of sunlight; I wasn’t likely to forget the smoky stink of it.
Gabriel crossed his arms over his chest. “Ethan’s told me about this menagerie theory, if that’s what we’re calling it. But Merit said she didn’t see an attraction like that at the carnival. What’s the point of having a menagerie if you aren’t going to show it off?”
Mallory raised a hand. “I’ve actually been thinking about that. It’s like an invitation-only sample sale.”
I got the comparison immediately, but the men just blinked with obvious befuddlement.
“Is this a food thing?” Catcher asked, earning a dramatic eye roll from Mallory.
“It’s a fashion thing,” she said. “It’s when designers sell their samples for a very large discount. Very exclusive.”
Understanding dawned in Ethan’s eyes. “You’re suggesting the public who attend the carnivals are not the target audience.”
She smiled. “Exactly. So maybe the menagerie is also exclusive. They bring the carnival to town but you don’t get in without an invitation.”
“And they also bring the sups,” Gabriel said with a nod. “Not as a carnival attraction, but a traveling menagerie. Same town, but separate location. Secret location, available only to certain well-heeled clientele.”
Ethan nodded. “That could fit. The motive, perhaps, isn’t about the sups. It’s about the ego, or perhaps the money. Impressing the hard to impress with an attraction they can’t see anywhere else in the world.”
Puzzle pieces fell into place. “And with every attack.”
They looked at me.
“Sentinel?” Ethan asked.
“Having a menagerie is one thing. But when you’ve got powerful magic, it’s not exactly a great story to just pluck someone off the street using it.”
“Like they might have done with Aline,” Ethan said.
I nodded. “Exactly. But if, to get the supernaturals, you have to fight for them? You set up an attack, claim your prey that way? Much more interesting story.”
“It’s a supernatural safari,” Ethan said.
“And it demands a higher ticket price,” Catcher said.
I nodded. “It would make sense, based on what we know.”
“So if you’re right, we’d be looking for someone insecure, or someone with a desire to impress,” Jeff said.
“Someone who needs to be needed,” Mallory added, “but doesn’t feel any obligation to follow the rules in doing it. Being popular is better than being good.”
“And yet,” Ethan said, “someone who believes they’ll find that fame or fortune in this fashion.”
We stood there silently for a moment, contemplating that somewhat pathetic, but entirely believable, profile.
Gabe looked at me. “I assume you haven’t yet determined where in Chicago the carnival might set up next?”
“Not yet. Catcher suggested we get the House on it. Maybe we can look at the carnival’s previous stops? See if there’s a pattern?”
Ethan nodded. “I’ll talk to Luc.”
Jeff nodded. “I’ll dig further into Regan’s ID, see if I can shake something loose there.” He looked to Catcher. “I’ll send you the photo. Maybe you can send it to Baumgartner, any other contacts you have, see if she looks familiar?”
“Will do.”
The fierce wail of a frustrated infant rang through the house. Gabriel smiled.
“Kid’s got some lungs.”
Ethan smiled. “So he does.”
“And I believe that’s probably my cue to exit stage right. What’s on your agenda?”
“Actually,” Mallory said, sharing a glance with Catcher, who nodded, “we’d like to go home.”
Gabriel’s brows lifted. “Oh?”
“If there’s a chance the carnival is headed back to Chicago,” Catcher said, “I’d like to be there, on the ground, and get the word out to sups, the Houses.”
“We came for Lup,” Mallory said, “and unfortunately that’s over. But considering what went down, we didn’t want to leave without checking with you first. We don’t want to make things worse.”
He was quiet for a moment. “Go home,” he said. “And thank you for your service. You did good out there. You stuck to your guts, to your heart, and you did that thing you do.”
She beamed with obvious delight at the praise. “Thank you, Gabe,” she said, laying a hand on his arm. “I suppose I’ll see you at the bar when you get back?”
“That you will,” Gabriel said.
Mallory and I exchanged hugs. “I’ll call you,” she said, rubbing my back before she released me again.
Catcher did the manly head-bob thing with the guys. “I’ll keep an eye and ear out in the Windy City. Talk to the supernatural community, see what I can find out. I’m going to have to give them a warning—tell them, at a minimum, to stay away from the carnival. We don’t know that’s how they do their targeting, but it’s all we’ve got. We can’t exactly tell them to avoid harpies and elves.”
“Although that’s also good advice,” Jeff said.
“Truth,” Catcher agreed. “I’ll let you know if I hear anything in the ether. And keep us posted.”
Ethan nodded. “Safe travels,” he said, and they walked to the door.
“How much longer will she work for you?” I asked Gabriel.
“Not much,” he said. “But she’s not quite there yet. She will be tested again.”
I slanted him a glance. “Is that prophecy or guesswork?”
He made a throaty laugh. “Is there a difference?”
You tell me, I thought. Gabriel had prophesied there was another set of “green eyes” in my future, eyes that looked much like Ethan’s. It seemed like a reference to a child, but since no vampire had successfully carried a child to term, that wasn’t actually a possibility.
But still.
“Two down, two to go,” Gabriel said, glancing at Ethan, a grin pulling up a corner of his mouth. “As you two have not yet solved this particular mystery, I presume you’ll be staying here.”
“We’re staying,” Ethan flatly said, “because the mayor still wants my hide and the Brecks have offered us shelter. In the meantime we’ll continue to investigate the menagerie.”
He glanced at his watch. “But at the moment, I think we’ll return to the carriage house. I need to check in, and we need to get the House started on research.” He glanced at my muddy pants and jacket. “And I presume my Sentinel would appreciate a change of clothes.”
“Cadogan’s Sentinel, if that’s what you meant to say, would appreciate a change of clothes. And a shower.”
Gabriel grinned. “She has your number, Sullivan.”
“And my heart, for better or worse.” He looked at me and smiled, ignoring the mixed company, and sent blood rushing to my cheeks.
Jeff cleared his throat. “So, I’m going to head to the Brecks’ ops room,” he said, tucking away his toy again. “Faster processors in there.”
“For searching, or for Jakob’s Quest?” I wondered.
It was Jeff’s turn to blush. “A little work, a little play, makes Jack a happy boy.”
Gabriel held up a hand. “I don’t need the details of how you and my sister spend your playtime, whelp.”
“And I don’t want to give them to you,” Jeff assured him. “Talk to you all later.”
Ethan and I said our good-byes, but before I could turn to follow Ethan to the door, Gabriel took my arm. I looked up, found his eyes intense and swirling.
“The future I once shared with you, Kitten. Do you think that’s prophecy or guesswork?”
I presumed he meant his green-eyes prediction, and my heart thudded against my chest.
I shook my head. “I don’t know.” My voice was barely a whisper. “You tell me.”
“It’s exactly what you think,” he said. “But there will be tests for you, as well.”
And with those words hanging in the air like so much ripe fruit, he disappeared, leaving me, heart pounding, standing in the hallway.
A child, with Ethan.
Gabriel had as much as confirmed it, even if he hadn’t said the words aloud. My heart blossomed with hope and love and possibility . . . and also fear. What had he meant by “tests”? I’d been attacked, seen my city nearly destroyed and my grandfather nearly killed, and I’d watched Ethan die to save my life. Was it the GP? Was it Ethan’s challenging Darius, or some injury he’d have to endure? And if a child was in our future, was our being together an inevitability? Or was Gabriel’s prophecy the shifter version of a devil’s bargain? Would I get exactly what I wanted, but with some horribly ironic twist?
“Are you all right?” Ethan asked as we walked back to the carriage house. “You seem tense.”
He was right. Gabriel’s words hung thick around my neck; once again, I was too unnerved to voice them to Ethan. I’d kept secrets from him before. Secrets I thought weren’t mine to tell, like my membership in the RG. Revealing that fact had put Jonah at risk as much as it did me.
“I’m fine,” I said as we stepped to the threshold and he turned the key, opened the door. The carriage house was empty, the pillows on the sofa bed tidy again. They’d already gone, leaving the two of us alone.
Ethan closed the door, locked it.
“No, I’m not fine,” I said, the words bursting out of me like air from a pricked balloon. “We need to talk.”